As a devoted aficionado of the Metroidvania genre, it’s fair to admit that we fans maintain exceptionally high expectations. While it’s often difficult to articulate the specific elements that define an outstanding Metroidvania, there’s an unmistakable sense of recognition when we encounter one that captures our interest.
This discerning outlook can sometimes lead us to overlook titles that don’t receive stellar reviews. However, many lower-rated Metroidvanias still offer engaging and worthwhile experiences. This article will shine a light on some hidden gems that, despite their less-than-perfect ratings, provide valuable contributions to the genre.
The games featured here have all scored below 80% on OpenCritic, but that doesn’t diminish their entertainment value. Whether they struggle with platforming mechanics, have a linear structure, or offer predictably simplistic gameplay, these titles manage to entertain and captivate players anyone who gives them a chance.
So, put away your critical lens and prepare for a journey through some underrated and enjoyable Metroidvanias that deserve your attention.
10 The Last Case of Benedict Fox
OpenCritic Score – 67
Let’s begin with The Last Case of Benedict Fox, which intriguingly blends Metroidvania gameplay with a dark, Lovecraftian atmosphere. This title weaves a murder mystery narrative starring a protagonist linked to a crafty demon. The unique setting serves as an engaging backdrop.
Visually, the game excels, though it does stumble with inconsistent combat and puzzles that range from brilliant to overly convoluted. A standout feature allows players to delve into the memories of the deceased, garnering insights that are refreshingly original for the genre.
If you can overlook its shortcomings, this dark Metroidvania has much to offer and stands out for its distinctive style.
9 INAYAH: Life After Gods
OpenCritic Score – 69
INAYAH: Life After Gods is filled with so much potential, it’s surprising its aggregate score isn’t higher. The artwork is visually striking, and the game features fast-paced and enjoyable platform action. Combat is where it really shines, thanks to the adaptable Gauntlet weapon that allows for a variety of choices, enhancing the thrill of battle.
However, the storytelling and character development fall flat. While the post-apocalyptic theme is interesting, getting invested in the narrative and characters can be a challenge. Coupled with a sprawling world map that often feels empty, one can understand its lukewarm reception. Still, for fans who appreciate solid platforming and combat, it remains a worthy choice.
8 Shadow Labyrinth
OpenCritic Score – 71
Shadow Labyrinth offers a peculiar and thrilling reinterpretation of the classic Pac-Man concept. In this imaginative game, players control Swordsman No.8, who is united with PUCK, an eerie, floating entity reminiscent of Pac-Man, yet far more sinister.
Despite its inventive premise, the game can be chaotic and less user-friendly than one might hope. Players may discover its layout is less straightforward than it initially appears, with many twists as the journey unfolds. Some design decisions, like facing bosses repeatedly, can be frustrating. Nevertheless, players who endure these hurdles will uncover a wonderfully creative experience.
7 Voidwrought
OpenCritic Score – 73
Another fascinating entry is Voidwrought, which carries a Lovecraftian ethos through its haunting narrative centered around the ominous Red Star and the extraction of Ichor—the gods’ blood. This narrative is a highlight, accompanied by gameplay that holds its own despite some apparent similarities to Hollow Knight.
The game’s main challenge lies in the learning curve associated with its mechanics—combat becomes easier as players discover diverse attack strategies, yet the initial difficulty can be quite demanding. It’s an ideal choice for those craving solace and rigor in their Metroidvania experience.
6 9 Years of Shadows
OpenCritic Score – 74
9 Years of Shadows showcases a captivating premise: players start with nothing in a desolate world and embark on a determined quest against dark forces that have taken everything from them. The visual presentation is stunning, with a floating teddy bear adding a touch of whimsy as it restores color to the otherwise monochromatic landscape.
While the Metroidvania exploration is enjoyable, the combat does not live up to expectations. Combat often feels repetitive, with a limited range of techniques that can lead to boredom, leaving only the thrilling boss encounters as a standout feature.
5 Forms: Steam & Cinder
OpenCritic Score – 74
In Gestalt: Steam & Cinder, players are treated to a gripping narrative filled with clever twists and fast-paced, engaging combat. Its impressive skill tree and stunning aesthetics further enrich the experience.
However, one significant drawback is its linearity. Players can navigate the entire game in under seven hours, which may leave some craving more depth and exploration. Here’s hoping that future sequels can extend this imaginative world while enhancing the gameplay balance and complexity.
4 Cookie Cutter
OpenCritic Score – 75
Cookie Cutter stands apart by reimagining the concept of being “bionic.”The story follows Cherry, a character rebuilt by an evil scientist, who embarks on an exhilarating quest for vengeance. Its visual design is notably striking, melding gruesome aesthetics with audacious creativity that leaves a lasting impression.
Combat also shines, although the parry system may frustrate players since success against many bosses depends on mastering it. For those in search of a visually compelling and bloodthirsty adventure, Cookie Cutter delivers in spades.
3 The Adventure Pals
OpenCritic Score – 76
From the creators of Cult of the Lamb, The Adventure Pals offers a whimsically offbeat experience starring a boy and his trusty giraffe. This colorful, cartoonish game evokes nostalgic vibes reminiscent of classics like Castle Crashers.
While the presentation is charming, there are small issues; the platforming may lack precision, and the difficulty level is on the easier side, somewhat diminishing the challenge. While not inherently negative, it may detract from the overall Metroidvania magic for some gamers.
2 Mandragora: Whispers Of The Witch Tree
OpenCritic Score – 76
In a refreshing twist, Mandragora allows players to create their own hero from a selection of six classes, enhancing customization within a dark, gritty world. This Soulslike Metroidvania captures players with its immersive aesthetic and challenging gameplay.
However, it may excel as an ARPG but lacks in delivering the sense of exploration that Metroidvanias are known for. Additionally, certain late-game boss fights and enemy positioning can prove excessively punishing, leading to a frustrating experience.
1 Venture to the Vile
OpenCritic Score – 73
Venture to the Vile presents an eccentric world set in Rainybrook, where residents wear animal masks, and a sinister force begins corrupting everything in its path. Players assume the role of a deer boy, transformed by this malevolent force, who sets out to rescue his friend, Ella.
This title stands out for its challenging combat, inventive Mutation-based upgrades, and unique gameplay mechanics that involve transitioning between foreground and background to conquer eerie settings. The bosses are particularly wild and memorable, showcasing the game’s creative scope. Despite its underwhelming score, Venture to the Vile offers an unforgettable experience that any Metroidvania fan should explore.
Leave a Reply