Since its release in 2014, Guardians of the Galaxy injected new life into the Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU). However, as the years have progressed, many aspects of this beloved trilogy have come under scrutiny. James Gunn’s trilogy uniquely illustrated the adventures of the Guardians, characterized by irreverent humor, a stellar soundtrack, and vibrant characters. While it initially captured the hearts of audiences, evolving viewer expectations have revealed that some elements of the Guardians saga have not aged well.
The inaugural Guardians of the Galaxy film is lauded as one of the finest entries in the MCU. The film ingeniously transformed a set of lesser-known Marvel heroes into household names, combining retro stylistic choices, poignant narratives, and a dynamic ensemble cast. Despite its critical and commercial acclaim, repeated viewings unveil certain issues that were perhaps overlooked amid the initial excitement. Although the movies excelled at creating unforgettable moments, components have emerged as tone-deaf or antiquated upon reflection.
10 Drax Bullying Mantis in Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 2
Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 2
The character Mantis, introduced in Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 2, embodies a naïve and trusting empath with a tragic past filled with abuse and isolation. Raised by Ego, she is conditioned to cater to his every desire, living a life devoid of meaningful connections, even referring to him as “Master.”
Drax’s entrance into her story is marked by what can only be described as relentless verbal abuse, where he disparages Mantis with terms like “ugly” and “disgusting.” His inappropriate humor—such as making gagging noises upon seeing her—transforms what could have been light-hearted banter into discomfort. Initially, her obliviousness was intended to be comedic, but it instead reveals the deeper issues surrounding bullying and insensitivity in humor, particularly as Mantis’s background makes her an easy target. This type of humor detracts from her character’s potential, rendering the audience complicit in her humiliation.
9 Underwhelming Villains in Vol. 1 & 2
Guardians of the Galaxy & Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 2
Both Guardians of the Galaxy films faced challenges in crafting compelling villains. In the original, Ronan the Accuser serves as a lackluster antagonist. Despite engaging performances from Lee Pace, Ronan’s character is simplistic and lacks the depth exhibited by other MCU villains such as Loki or Killmonger. His role feels more like an obstacle for the Guardians rather than a fleshed-out character with real motivations.
The sequel presents Ego the Living Planet, who benefits from Kurt Russell’s charismatic portrayal. However, the character’s abstract motivations—for his desire for universal domination—come across as vague and underdeveloped. Without emotional stakes, Ego fails to be a genuinely engaging villain. As a series known for its colorful characters and inventive narratives, its struggle to create memorable antagonists is a noteworthy flaw that undermines the overall story impact.
8 Peter Quill’s “Dance-Off” Solution Was Anticlimactic
Guardians of the Galaxy
In the climax of Guardians of the Galaxy, Peter Quill’s unconventional strategy to defeat Ronan with a “dance-off” understandably aligns with the film’s light-hearted spirit. However, this conclusion undermines any emotional and narrative gravity previously established in the story. A culmination of tension that builds throughout the film should deliver a meaningful payoff, but instead transitions into a comic moment that risks diluting the stakes and reducing Ronan’s character to a mere punchline.
While humorous for audiences upon release, a more recent perspective on this scene reveals it as an anticlimactic resolution that sacrifices emotional depth for comedic relief. Moreover, it diminishes Ronan’s fearsome abilities and ultimately affects the narrative weight of the film.
7 The Sequels Failed to Recapture the Original’s Magic
Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 2 & Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 3
The original installment of Guardians of the Galaxy achieved a masterful balance of humor, heart, and action, cementing its status as a standout MCU entry. The film’s distinctive quality stemmed from its portrayal of a rag-tag ensemble overcoming adversity, underlined by an iconic soundtrack and emotionally resonant character moments. Regrettably, Vol. 2 and Vol. 3 fell short of this charm.
The second installment leaned excessively on sentimentality and humor, often at the cost of cohesive storytelling. This led to a narrative that wandered, introducing superficial emotional beats. By the time Vol. 3 made its debut, the novelty of the Guardians’ antics had diminished. Though both sequels included standout moments, they lacked the originality that differentiated the first film. Consequently, these later installments serve as echoes of the initial magic rather than successful continuations of its exceptional legacy.
6 The Soundtracks Became Underwhelming
Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 2 & Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 3
The music in the Guardians films has become a hallmark of the series, with the original mixtape significantly contributing to its charm. Classic tracks like “Come and Get Your Love” and “Hooked on a Feeling” resonated deeply with the narrative, heightening the emotional depth and quirky tone of the film. The music became integral to its success.
However, the soundtracks of the subsequently released films have often felt disappointingly uninspired. Though Vol. 2 and Vol. 3 included notable songs, they struggled to recapture the magic of the original mixtape. The song selections sometimes appear uninspired and less cohesive, lacking the blend of hits and hidden gems that characterized the original. Instead of enhancing the storyline, the music started to feel more like an opportunistic marketing tactic rather than a crucial component of the narrative.
5 Drax Calls Gamora a “Green Whore”
Guardians of the Galaxy
In the first installment, Drax refers to Gamora as a “green whore”during a heated exchange. Although the comment is framed as a misunderstanding—Drax misinterpreting another character’s dialogue—the delivery of such a harsh insult toward one of the film’s few strong female characters feels jarring. This remark leaves a bitter aftertaste, as it undermines Gamora’s character, who is portrayed as a formidable warrior.
Despite its contextualization, this instance serves as a reflection of the stagnant humor that hasn’t aged well, especially within the context of today’s sensitivity towards derogatory terms. Drax’s comment seems out of place, contrasting sharply with contemporary attitudes towards respectful dialogue.
4 Rocket Raccoon Mocks an Amputee
Guardians of the Galaxy
Rocket Raccoon’s sharp demeanor and biting humor often define his character. Yet, certain jokes, particularly his taunts towards an amputee in the first film, reveal a darker edge to his humor. While intended to showcase his cheeky nature, the moment feels harsh and out of place.
This scene may be interpreted as a reflection of Rocket’s internal struggles with his own traumatic experiences. However, the jab at the amputee leans heavily on cruelty, resulting in a stark contrast against the nuanced trauma explored later in Vol. 3. Such moments undercut Rocket’s character development, painting him as unnecessarily callous for mere comedic effect.
3 Yondu’s Fatherhood Flip
Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 2
One of the most emotionally charged moments in Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 2 arises from Yondu’s ultimate sacrifice for Peter Quill. However, this poignant reveal is somewhat undermined by Yondu’s portrayal in the first film, where he is characterized as abusive and morally ambiguous. His rapid transition to a sympathetic father figure feels hasty and unearned.
Although Yondu’s ultimate act of heroism resonates deeply, it poses questions about the authenticity of his redemption arc. This abrupt character transformation—shifting from villain to surrogate father—feels convenient, drawing on emotional manipulation rather than a thoughtfully constructed character development. While the sacrifice may tug at heartstrings, it risks coming across as rushed and underdeveloped.
2 Thin Female Character Arcs
Guardians of the Galaxy, Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 2, Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 3
The trilogy has faced criticism for its underdeveloped female characters, such as Gamora, Mantis, and Nebula. While they possess intriguing backgrounds, they often take a backseat to their male counterparts. Gamora’s significant character exploration primarily occurs in the Avengers films, limiting her depth in the Guardians series, whereas Nebula’s narrative richness is largely unveiled in later entries of the MCU.
Mantis serves more as comic relief, lacking agency and development throughout the trilogy. Instead of showcasing her strength, her portrayal often leans into negative stereotypes, depicting her as naive and subservient. This disparity in character development highlights a significant shortcoming in the trilogy and detracts from the overall richness of the ensemble cast.
1 Drax’s Comedy Became Over-the-Top
Guardians of the Galaxy, Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 2, Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 3
As the trilogy progresses, Drax’s comedic role devolves into over-the-top antics, overshadowing the complexity that initially defined his character. In the first film, his humor contrasted poignantly with his tragic background, making it both relatable and endearing. However, by the time of Vol. 3, Drax has largely been relegated to pure comic relief, with his serious dimensions downplayed.
This transformation reflects a broader trend within the trilogy, where the balance between humor and emotional narrative often tips towards slapstick, sacrificing depth for laughter. In hindsight, this comedic shift has not aged well, revealing a lack of growth and understanding of character dynamics that diminishes the trilogy’s significance.
Leave a Reply