10 Major Plot Holes That Mass Effect 5 Must Address

The Mass Effect universe captivates players with rich narratives and compelling characters. The original trilogy and its spin-off, Andromeda, crafted a vast and intimate storyline, leaving an indelible mark on fans’ memories and a longing for more adventures. However, even beloved sagas present challenges, and as anticipation builds for Mass Effect 5, it’s paramount to address the lingering questions and inconsistencies that have left fans pondering, particularly following the polarizing conclusion of Mass Effect 3 and the separate narrative trajectory of Andromeda.

The forthcoming title offers an exceptional opportunity to reset and clarify unresolved issues. Rather than sidestepping the existing narrative gaps, BioWare can demonstrate their commitment to storytelling by offering coherent explanations and resolving longstanding debates. From the true nature of the Reapers to the significance of Shepard’s choices, providing clarity on these topics could foster trust and excitement as players prepare for Mass Effect 5.

10 How Much of the Indoctrination Theory Was Correct?

Unreliable Storytelling – Or Something Else?

Mass Effect 5 should thoroughly investigate the Indoctrination Theory, even if it remains ambiguous. Questions surrounding Shepard’s fate at the conclusion of Mass Effect 3—such as whether the endings were genuine or if the Reapers had manipulated events—demand attention. These inquiries merit exploration rather than dismissal.

By employing devices like unreliable narration, fragmented memories, or subtle hints that suggest Shepard’s perceptions may be distorted, the game can deepen the narrative. Addressing indoctrination could not only clarify the perplexities surrounding the end of Mass Effect 3 but also enhance the overall understanding of the trilogy. This approach could introduce an intriguing new threat as the series progresses, enriching Shepard’s journey and the franchise as a whole.

9 Who Really Started the Crucible?

The Protheans Only Continued It

Clarifying the origins of the Crucible is vital for Mass Effect 5. Although the game positions it as an ancient artifact, akin to the Citadel and Mass Relays, this revelation raises crucial inquiries: Did it originate from prior cycles of civilizations, or is it another ploy by the Reapers to manipulate civilizations into futile endeavors? The ambiguity surrounding its creation heightens the atmosphere of deceit that permeates the Mass Effect series.

Despite being a focal point, the Crucible ultimately fails to deliver on players’ expectations. Its whimsical choices and the introduction of the Star Child contribute to its unclear purpose, which in turn bolsters the Indoctrination Theory. Addressing its origins thoughtfully can enrich the narrative tapestry of Mass Effect 5.

8 Did the Krogans Start War With the Galaxy Again?

They Have A History & Are Cured Of The Genophage

One significant concern for Mass Effect 5 is the potential resurgence of Krogan aggression. Following their liberation from the genophage, their capacity for reproduction could kindle ambitions for dominance. This creates uncertainty about whether they might instigate conflicts against other species.

Addressing this potential conflict is crucial for maintaining the fragile balance within the galaxy. Overlooking it would mean missing an opportunity to delve into the ramifications of past choices while revisiting themes of conflict, accountability, and the cyclical nature of violence that defined the original trilogy.

7 What Do Quarians Look Like Under Their Helmets?

We Were Told There’d Be A Real Answer Already

The fascination surrounding the appearance of Quarians remains unresolved in the Mass Effect narrative. Despite hints offered through Tali’s character arc, a definitive reveal is crucial for Mass Effect 5. This mystery has long captivated fans, especially since earlier DLCs altered earlier clues.

A clear depiction of their appearance would not only quell fans’ curiosity but also provide closure to an enduring enigma. Considering the Quarians’ integral role within the larger story, unveiling their faces would foster a deeper connection between players and Quarian characters, enhancing the cultural aspects of the narrative.

6 Who Was the Benefactor of the Andromeda Initiative?

One Part of Andromeda You Can Answer

Unraveling the identity of the benefactor behind the Andromeda Initiative is a critical loose end for Mass Effect 5 to address. This enigmatic figure financed the initiative while being acutely aware of the Reaper threat in the Milky Way, yet never seem to benefit from it directly.

Identifying this benefactor could shift players’ perceptions of the Andromeda Initiative and potentially link it to known factions like Cerberus or the Illusive Man, creating an intriguing bridge between the two galaxies.

5 How Can Mass Relays Get Destroyed Without Major Galactic Consequences?

Arrival DLC Proved It Does A Lot of Damage

Mass Effect 5 must confront the narrative complications that arise from the destruction of mass relays. This plot hole undermines the profound repercussions depicted in the original trilogy. The Arrival DLC illustrates the extensive devastation triggered by relay destruction across star systems, yet the conclusion of Mass Effect 3 implies that such calamity affects only the relays.

This discrepancy weakens the series’ core themes surrounding risk and sacrifice. To ensure consistency in the narrative, addressing this plot hole is critical. The game could either redefine the mechanics of relays, amplify the consequences of their destruction, or present an explanation for their rapid restoration as seen in the initial post-ME3 DLC. Failing to resolve this inconsistency could jeopardize the established lore and diminish the impact of Mass Effect 5.

4 What Happened To The Human Reaper?

Is Mass Effect Going To Keep Ignoring It?

The destiny of the Human-Reaper must be a pivotal topic for Mass Effect 5. Its creation in Mass Effect 2 offered significant insights into the Reapers’ methodologies and underscored the chilling ambitions of Cerberus. However, the narrative largely neglected this thread in Mass Effect 3. Should it continue to be overlooked, the horror associated with it may become diminished. Fans need clarity on whether Cerberus succeeded in their ambitions.

Delving into this storyline could provide insights into the Reapers’ overarching objectives and exemplify the threats posed by uncontrolled technology, echoing the series’ central themes of manipulation and moral decay. Disregarding the fate of the Human-Reaper would squander an opportunity for narrative resolution and thematic depth.

3 How Did Anderson and the Illusive Man Get To the Citadel Before Shepard?

Hackett Clearly Said No One Made It

The appearance of Anderson and the Illusive Man on the Citadel prior to Shepard in Mass Effect 3 poses a narrative inconsistency that requires rectification in Mass Effect 5. Their seemingly impossible arrival, amid chaos and tight security, disrupts the story, leading to confusion among players. This point has fueled support for the Indoctrination Theory, and without it, this inconsistency would be simply poor writing.

2 How Did A Rachni Survive To The Third Game?

“Somehow, The Rachni Returned”

The sudden reappearance of the Rachni Queen in Mass Effect 3 contradicts the choices players made previously and creates substantial narrative issues. In the first installment, players faced a pivotal decision: save or destroy the Rachni Queen. If the Queen was eradicated, her existence in the third game becomes incoherent.

Another queen appears without explanation, undermining the significance of player decisions made in the original game. Ignoring this inconsistency risks portraying players’ choices as inconsequential, which is counterproductive to the series’ ethos. To maintain the franchise’s integrity and honor player agency, Mass Effect 5 must offer a coherent explanation rather than a vague assertion that a new queen was concealed.

1 What Happened To The Andromeda Initiative?

Don’t Ignore The Mass Effect Step Child

To properly tie up loose narrative threads, Mass Effect 5 must address the fate of the Andromeda Initiative post-game. Following the events of Andromeda, the Initiative faced multifaceted challenges, including resource shortages and questionable leadership, all within a perilous environment. Failing to acknowledge these difficulties risks rendering the decisions of Ryder and the pathfinders meaningless.

Given that a considerable time has passed, players deserve insights on the Initiative’s fate—perhaps through prophetic visions or other narrative devices. While this may sound absurd, the Mass Effect franchise is known for embracing the unexpected.

Understanding what transpires with the Andromeda Initiative is critical, as it connects back to the Milky Way. The inhabitants of Andromeda symbolize refugees fleeing the Reaper threat, and their stories are significant for the fans who endured challenges with the series during less favorable times. Addressing this narrative thread is essential for crafting a compelling and cohesive story that resonates with longstanding fans of the Mass Effect saga.

Source & Images