The DC Universe has undergone numerous variations throughout its cinematic history, leading to numerous memorable scenes that some argue might have been better in different films. As we look ahead to James Gunn’s upcoming era for DC, many fans are taking the time to reflect on previous adaptations to understand the shifts that are about to unfold. This exploration often sidesteps the newer DCU Chapter One to revisit beloved characters and iconic moments from earlier iterations of DC Comics on screen.
From the sprawling timeline of the DC Extended Universe (DCEU) to the critically acclaimed standalone films like Christopher Nolan’s The Dark Knight trilogy or Tim Burton’s Batman series, the cinematic portrayal of DC heroes has been rich and varied. A number of scenes have resonated deeply with audiences, evoking nostalgia and a desire to see more of their favorite characters portrayed effectively. While James Gunn’s prospective Superman film is expected to carry the legacy forward, it raises questions about certain pivotal moments from earlier films that could have shone brighter in alternative contexts.
10 Batman Teaches The Flash A Lesson
Original Movie – The Flash (2023)
In a poignant moment from 2023’s The Flash, Barry Allen, portrayed by Ezra Miller, confides in Bruce Wayne, played by Ben Affleck, about his desire to reverse time to save his mother. Bruce, drawing from his own tragic experiences, warns Barry against such actions. This dynamic sequence stands out not just for its emotional depth but also for character development. However, critics noted that the film’s over-reliance on CGI diminished the scene’s overall impact.
Imagining this moment within the framework of a more grounded Batman film could have amplified its significance, providing a better backdrop for Bruce’s wisdom and enriching the narrative for both characters. By relocating this scene to a hypothetical solo Batman film, it would serve to deepen Bruce’s characterization while subtly integrating the upcoming Flash narrative.
9 The Green Lantern Corps Are Revealed
Original Movie – Green Lantern (2011)
2011’s Green Lantern is often regarded as a notable disappointment in superhero cinema, receiving negative critical reception and failing at the box office. However, one of its most memorable moments—the introduction of the Green Lantern Corps—holds a special place for comic enthusiasts, marking their first appearance in live-action. Yet, the overall quality of the film casts a shadow over this significant scene.
Reimagining the reveal of the Green Lantern Corps within a more competent standalone film or a wider Justice League context could have enhanced its impact. As a stinger in a larger narrative, this moment could have fostered audience investment in the DC universe while paving the way for future metahuman stories, rather than marred by the lackluster reception of its parent film.
8 Gary Puddles’ Testimony
Original Movie – Joker: Madness of Two (2024)
One of the standout scenes from Joker: Folie à Deux is Gary Puddles’ heartbreaking testimony during Arthur Fleck’s trial. This moment evokes a powerful emotional response, connecting deeply to the themes explored in the 2019 film, where Arthur’s descent into the Joker persona leaves a path of suffering.
However, the sequel’s lukewarm reception diminished the moment’s resonance. Had Puddles’ testimony been incorporated into the first film, it could have magnified its emotional weight and solidified the stakes surrounding Arthur’s transformation into the Joker, all within a more widely acclaimed narrative.
7 The Death Of Superman
Original Movie – Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice (2016)
The death of Superman at the hands of Doomsday in Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice is a pivotal moment that sparked major reactions among fans. While it certainly shakes the foundations of the DC Universe, its execution felt somewhat rushed and could have benefited from additional context in a dedicated Superman film. This major plot point could have unfolded with greater emotional stakes had it followed two or three established films focusing on Superman’s character development.
Additionally, this would have provided an opportunity to explore Superman’s relationships, particularly with Batman, further solidifying the emotional repercussions of his demise. Having Superman’s death serve as a catalyst for forming the Justice League could resonate more profoundly had the groundwork for character arcs been laid out beforehand.
6 Aquaman & Black Manta’s Final Fight
Original Movie – Aquaman and The Lost Kingdom (2023)
Aquaman’s final showdown with Black Manta in Aquaman and The Lost Kingdom is marked by vibrant action. Nonetheless, the film’s overall reception hindered the emotional stakes surrounding this confrontation. As Black Manta was influenced by the spirit Kordax, the personal vendetta built in the first Aquaman was diluted.
Revisiting their dynamic from the original film would have allowed for an emotionally charged conclusion, giving more weight to their conflict. Given the apparent underperformance of the sequel, viewers may have preferred to witness Black Manta’s arc as a primary antagonist in the earlier film, culminating in this highly anticipated clash.
5 Batman’s Chase Of The Joker & Harley Quinn
Original Movie – Suicide Squad (2016)
In Suicide Squad (2016), a brief flashback showcases Batman pursuing the Joker and Harley Quinn. While this scene has great potential, its placement within a chaotic narrative diminishes its significance. The absence of a robust Batman solo film to showcase his ongoing rivalry with the Joker feels like a missed opportunity.
4 Cyborg’s Backstory Scenes
Original Movie – Zack Snyder’s Justice League (2021)
One of the most significant differences between the 2017 theatrical version and Zack Snyder’s Justice League is Cyborg’s character development. Snyder’s version afforded him a deeply emotional backstory that resonated profoundly with audiences. The theatrical cut, meanwhile, removed this vital aspect altogether, leading to a disconnection from the character’s motivations.
This underscores how pivotal Cyborg’s narrative could have been to the earlier theatrical release. His story should have been a cornerstone of the film, enhancing both character-driven narratives and the overall emotional depth of the Justice League assembly.
3 Blue Beetle’s DCEU Hero Debut
Original Movie – Blue Beetle (2023)
Blue Beetle’s introduction came late in the lifecycle of the DCEU and was well-received compared to earlier titles like Shazam! Fury of the Gods and The Flash. However, its release raised concerns about whether the character would continue into the new DCU. A more strategic introduction within an earlier ensemble film or even as a teaser could have built anticipation for his solo debut, ensuring his narrative relevance in upcoming projects.
2 Martian Manhunter’s DCEU Debut
Original Movie – Zack Snyder’s Justice League (2021)
The introduction of Martian Manhunter in Zack Snyder’s Justice League was a moment steeped in anticipation for fans. However, relocating this reveal to a more extensive universe could have generated greater excitement. Utilizing this scene as a post-credits reveal in 2017’s Justice League would have placed a spotlight on this iconic character and built intrigue for a potential future.
1 Michael Keaton’s Batman Action Scenes
Original Movie – The Flash (2023)
Michael Keaton’s return as Batman in The Flash offered nostalgic excitement for long-time fans of the character. However, the action scenes featuring his portrayal served as a bittersweet reminder that he was not positioned to continue in the broader DC universe. The technological advancements ushered in by 2023 allowed for an exciting reinterpretation of his character, but many believe his legacy would have been better served in a standalone installment showcasing his earlier adventures.
Leave a Reply