10 Films That Blurred the Lines of Musical Genre

Identifying a musical film can be straightforward, yet certain exceptions complicate this classification. Numerous films showcase music performances and incorporate musical scenes, but that doesn’t necessarily align them with traditional musicals. A movie that features songs performed on stage or played on the radio contrasts with a true musical, where characters express their emotions through spontaneous song. This distinction raises important questions regarding the definition of a musical film and the fundamental criteria required for such classification.

Interestingly, many films classified as “sort-of-musicals”boast a comparable number of songs to actual musicals. However, their more realistic approach leads them to be categorized under different genres. These films creatively utilize music in significant ways while refraining from being labeled as musicals, despite the pivotal role songs play in their narratives.

10. Pitch Perfect (2011)

Using Music to Depict Character Growth

At its core, Pitch Perfect is a comedic film enriched with musical features, particularly through its stage performances. The storyline revolves around an all-female college a cappella group striving to modernize their performance style and attract a larger audience. This film presents numerous musically gifted performers, granting them a vibrant platform to showcase their talents.

The film cleverly uses music to illustrate character transformations. Much like a sports movie, Pitch Perfect follows various competitions that highlight pivotal moments in the characters’ journeys. The absence of spontaneous song in non-performance settings prevents it from being fully classified as a musical, yet its approach to music-driven storytelling mirrors that of traditional musicals.

9. Coco (2017)

Pixar’s Most Musical Offering

Unlike its Disney counterparts known for their animated musicals, Pixar has been more reserved in this genre. An exception stands out: Coco, which chronicles a young boy’s journey into the Land of the Dead to uncover his family’s heritage. This heartwarming story emphasizes family values while simultaneously celebrating the unifying power of music and the enduring memories it can create.

While Coco doesn’t fully fit the musical mold, its songs are instrumental to the narrative. The variations of “Remember Me”serve to represent Miguel’s differing relationships with music, highlighting both its glamour and emotional depth. Boasting an impressive soundtrack, engaging characters, and a poignant conclusion, Coco remains one of Pixar’s finest productions.

8. Eurovision Song Contest: The Story of Fire Saga (2020)

A Unique Take on a European Phenomenon

Eurovision Song Contest: The Story of Fire Saga presents a fictional narrative centered on an authentic music competition. Although Eurovision’s popularity has expanded globally, it remains a well-loved tradition across Europe, occasionally confounding outsiders. The film, however, cleverly mines humor from these cultural peculiarities.

Featuring Will Ferrell and Rachel McAdams as sibling contestants from Iceland, the movie includes several of their original songs alongside performances from fellow competitors. Despite the musical elements, the film comments on the strangeness of the competition within its comedic context—allowing for an indulgent musical number featuring genuine Eurovision legends.

7. The Boat That Rocked (2009)

A British Comedy Rooted in History

Known in North America as Pirate Radio, The Boat That Rocked explores the story of a radio station broadcasting from a ship in the North Sea during the 1960s. While the characters and station are fictional, the film draws inspiration from actual historical broadcasts, enveloped in the vibrant 1960s counterculture aesthetic. The film features iconic tracks from legendary bands like The Who, The Kinks, and Cream.

While the characters themselves aren’t musicians, music plays a vital role in shaping the film’s cultural narrative and personal relationships. Richard Curtis could have easily transformed this piece into a traditional musical, but it instead focuses on the profound influence of music across societal lines, ensuring that the love for music remains the central theme.

6. Yellow Submarine (1968)

An Animated Tribute to Artistic Expression

While films like A Hard Day’s Night and Help! may primarily appeal to ardent Beatles fans, Yellow Submarine can be appreciated by a broader audience, as it combines psychedelic animation with inventive visuals that complement The Beatles’ music. Although it doesn’t quite fit the traditional musical framework, the music is integral enough that one could consider it a visual album or an extended music video, though those labels fall short as well.

As one of the most unique animated features ever produced, Yellow Submarine has been credited with revitalizing the animation industry, carving a new path distinct from the Disney style. It utilizes The Beatles’ music as its foundation while creatively innovating with diverse art styles and visual storytelling techniques.

5. Guardians of the Galaxy (2014)

Character Insights Through Music

Guardians of the Galaxy intricately weaves music into the narrative, utilizing it to enhance character development and to set the mood in key scenes. Director James Gunn carefully curates the soundtrack, ensuring each track aligns seamlessly with its respective moment. The “Awesome Mix”used by Peter Quill features beloved hits from the 1960s and 1970s.

For Quill, a human stranded in space, the cassette player holds sentimental value as his only connection to Earth. Each song resonates deeply with him, amplifying the film’s emotional depth. Ultimately, music serves as a central element in his struggle against the antagonist, culminating in a comically memorable dance-off that showcases the unique synergy between music and storytelling throughout the series.

4. Inside Llewyn Davis (2013)

A Glimpse into the Music Industry

Inside Llewyn Davis, often viewed as a roman-à-clef about Bob Dylan’s life, offers a captivating exploration of the Greenwich Village folk scene, illustrating the cyclical struggles musicians face. The conclusion reveals Llewyn witnessing Dylan perform, clarifying the Coen brothers’ inspirations, regardless of personal interpretations regarding Dylan’s influence.

Marking the film’s journey, musical performances provide insight into the era’s music industry, contrasting Llewyn’s heartfelt, introspective songs with the superficial pop music he is obliged to perform. While it may not be the most acclaimed Coen brothers’ work, Inside Llewyn Davis captivates audiences with its insightful portrayal of music and a standout performance by Oscar Isaac.

3. This Is Spinal Tap (1984)

Comedy Through Musical Parody

Rob Reiner’s pioneering rock mockumentary, This Is Spinal Tap, remains one of the most celebrated comedies in cinematic history. With the highly anticipated sequel in the works, fans will have the opportunity to explore the band’s journey four decades later, reflecting on their relevance and the peculiar circumstances surrounding previous band members.

The original film’s humor arises from the juxtaposition of Spinal Tap’s rock music with their mundane day-to-day lives. The contrast between their bombastic stage personas and their ordinary life off-stage sparks constant hilarity. This dissonance creates a unique ambiance that would falter if the film were conceived as a true musical.

2. Maria (2024)

A Biographical Dive into Art and Music

Angelina Jolie has garnered acclaim for her portrayal in Maria, the third installment in Pablo Larraín’s trilogy exploring significant women of the 20th century. Following the acclaimed Jackie and Spencer, Maria presents a fresh perspective by focusing on music and artistry rather than merely political narratives, with Jolie embodying the legendary opera singer Maria Callas.

Music weaves through every facet of the film, demonstrating its paramount importance in Callas’ life, despite her loss of vocal ability and subsequent exit from the limelight. Maria is a poignant drama that navigates themes of loss and identity while confronting the relentless judgment from the public eye. Unlike typical music biopics that often rely on nostalgia, Maria is deft and reflective, seamlessly integrating music into the narrative.

1. School of Rock (2003)

Transitioning to a True Musical

Richard Linklater’s films frequently incorporate music, capturing the essence of specific periods and locales, with School of Rock standing out as his closest endeavor to a full-fledged musical. Known for other films like Dazed & Confused, this film initially features a few original songs, focusing on Jack Black as a rock enthusiast who inspires an unassuming group of students to form a band.

Throughout this journey, he imparts essential lessons about music, its rich history, and the spirit of rock and roll culture. School of Rock eventually transitioned into a successful stage musical, adapted by Andrew Lloyd Webber. This adaptation introduced additional original songs, firmly establishing it as a genuine musical.

Source & Images