The world of Doctor Who is rife with fan theories, some of which have blossomed into confirmed truths, while others have been unequivocally debunked. Enthusiastic audiences continuously ponder the future of the show, drawing speculation from canonical events that have spanned over six decades. The magnetic allure of Doctor Who prompts fans to generate a slew of predictions, eagerly following the adventures of the Doctor and companions. Nonetheless, many theories, once believed to hold weight, are dismissed when new narrative elements emerge.
Much of Doctor Who’s enduring charm lies in its storytelling, which captivates viewers and incites speculation about potential plot twists and character revelations. Occasionally, wild theories indeed turn out to be true, further igniting the imagination of the show’s ardent followers. However, there are significant ideas about various characters—ranging from the true identity of the Master to the lineage of companions—that have been tragically disproven.
10
Rory Williams Is The Master
Audiences Often Speculated That New Characters Were Villains
One of the more outrageous theories suggested that Rory Williams was an incarnation of the Master. This speculation arose in part from Rory’s deep connection with the Doctor and his notable involvement in the storylines. However, no canonical evidence supports this idea after many years have passed since the Ponds’ departure in “The Angels Take Manhattan.”Furthermore, the Master has never indicated any interactions while traveling as Rory, effectively discrediting the theory.
Moreover, if Rory were indeed the Master, it would raise questions about his relationships, particularly his connection to River Song, a character who possesses Time Lord DNA due to her conception within the TARDIS’s Time Vortex. The Master’s typical behavior, which often includes contriving havoc, stands in stark contrast to Rory’s character, making this theory unlikely at best.
9
Susan Twist Is The Doctor’s Granddaughter
The Mysterious Character Susan Twist… Not Quite
Since her departure during the classic era, fans have longed for the return of Susan Foreman, the Doctor’s granddaughter. When the name Susan Twist surfaced in the credits of season 14, speculation erupted. It seemed plausible that this new character would link back to the beloved companion, especially given her presence in several episodes alongside the Doctor and Ruby, leading to tantalizing theories. The catchphrase “There’s always a twist at the end”further fueled viewers’ hopes.
However, the Doctor’s initial reaction upon meeting Susan Triad, the real character behind the name, confirmed that she was not his granddaughter. The UNIT organization speculated about this possibility, but the Doctor dismissed it. Ultimately, Triad was swept across time by Sutekh, serving a completely different narrative purpose. While her appearance sparked interest, the theory was ultimately laid to rest by the Doctor’s authoritative claim.
8
Donna Noble Picked Up The Master’s Ring
The Actual Reveal Was A Letdown
The notion that Donna Noble might have picked up the Master’s ring at the conclusion of “Last of the Time Lords”was a thought-provoking, albeit humorous, theory. Despite its intricacies, many fans struggled to rationalize why Donna would align herself with the Master. Speculation arose that he might have coerced her, but given Donna’s strong-willed nature, this seemed improbable.
This theory gained traction particularly as Catherine Tate’s return as Donna was announced shortly after the episode aired, creating high expectations. Yet, when the truth revealed itself, it was an underwhelming moment, contrasting sharply with the fanfare that followed the theory’s emergence.
7
Clara Is The Doctor & River’s Daughter
The Parentage of Clara Oswald
Another theory that captured the imagination of Doctor Who fans was the idea that Clara Oswald was the daughter of the Doctor and River Song. This speculation gained momentum following the conclusion of the time-traveling Pond era and Clara’s initial introduction in season 7. Many fans believed that the dynamics between Clara and the Twelfth Doctor implied a familial connection, resembling a parent-child bond.
However, this theory falls flat upon careful examination. Steven Moffat’s penchant for layered storytelling does not imply a hidden lineage when it was already made clear in earlier episodes. The relationship between Clara and the Doctor hints at complexity, but there is no textual evidence to support the theory. Moreover, referencing River Song’s established storyline would complicate things needlessly without substantial narrative justification.
6
Ashildr Is Romana
The Identity of Maisie Williams’ Character
The character of Ashildr, portrayed by Maisie Williams in season 9, stirred significant theories among fans, leading to speculation that she might be the Doctor’s former companion Romana. This connection arose in part due to Ashildr’s interactions with intriguing creatures in promotional materials, prompting viewers to draw parallels to Romana’s time within the series.
Despite the initial plausibility, further development cemented that Ashildr was not Romana. While fans hoped for a nostalgic return of a classic character, Ashildr’s own narrative arc, which included her ties to the Time Lords, clearly established her unique identity within the Doctor Who lore.
5
Omega Is Behind The Silence
The Silence and Their True Origin
Fans speculated that Omega—Gallifrey’s legendary engineer who had seemingly met his end—was orchestrating the actions of the Silence, a major adversary during the Eleventh Doctor’s storyline. Theories proliferated, suggesting Omega’s return and his hand in manipulating events leading to the Doctor’s supposed demise.
Nevertheless, it was revealed that the Silence were, in fact, a religious order aiming to suppress the Doctor’s insight into his own identity. This unraveling occurred well after the Ponds left, showing that Omega’s narrative was separate and debunking the speculation that had gathered momentum within the fandom during earlier seasons.
4
The Monks Are Actually Cybermen
Monks vs. Cybermen: The Great Debate
As anticipation built for Doctor Who season 10, the return of the Mondasian Cybermen was met with widespread excitement. Concurrently, the introduction of the Monks led to speculation about their potential origins as a pre-conversion form of the Cybermen.
Eventually, viewers learned that the Monks were not linked to the Cybermen’s legacy at all. Instead, these creatures were revealed to be shape-shifters orchestrating their own invasion. While this intriguing theory captured imaginations, it ultimately faced the harsh light of canon that clarified the Monks’ distinct identity.
3
Maestro Is The Master
The Arrival of Jinkx Monsoon and Speculation
The announcement of Jinkx Monsoon joining the cast of Doctor Who fueled fan theories, particularly regarding the character’s name, Maestro. Many jumped to the conclusion that Maestro must be the Master, especially considering the drama surrounding the timely return of beloved characters.
When the character debuted in “The Devil’s Chord,”expectations ran high, but viewers were surprised to find that Maestro was a member of the Pantheon instead of the anticipated Master. While the reveal was unexpected, many fans were left feeling that their hopes of seeing the Master return were dashed.
2
Adam Mitchell Is Davros
The Resemblance to the Creator of the Daleks
The brief run of Adam Mitchell as a companion during the Ninth Doctor’s era gave rise to a theory connecting him to Davros, the infamous creator of the Daleks. Certain features of Adam—particularly the technology he acquires—fueled speculation about a potential shared legacy.
However, subsequent encounters with Davros confirmed that Adam plays no part in this storyline. In turn, Adam’s narrative evolved to assail the Doctor rather than align with his fate, further distancing him from the iconic villain and offering an intriguing post-TARDIS life.
1
The Eleventh Doctor Is Melody Pond’s Father
Speculation Surrounding Amy’s Parentage Choices
One of the most resounding yet convoluted theories maintained by audiences was the idea that the Eleventh Doctor was actually the biological father of Melody Pond. This theory gained traction following a kiss exchanged between Amy and the Doctor in season 5, and intensified after Rory’s revival made viewers wonder about Amy’s fidelity.
The melodramatic implications were alluring but led to confusion given the timeline, especially since River Song is later positioned as the Doctor’s wife. Throughout “A Good Man Goes to War,”viewers learned that her Time Lord lineage is a product of circumstance, effectively laying this theory to rest. The narrative intricacies surrounding River and the Doctor reinforced that their connections were far more complex than simple parentage.
Related Articles:
First Look: Wes Anderson’s ‘The Phoenician Scheme’ Stuns at CinemaCon
4:46
‘Because I Knew You’: My Perspective After Watching ‘Wicked: For Good’ Footage
4:42
Cast of ‘Jurassic World: Rebirth’ Discusses Filming Challenges for Their New Dinosaur Adventure
23:47
Leave a Reply