10 Common Misconceptions About Supernatural That Fans Often Get Wrong

Debunking Common Misconceptions About Supernatural

Created by Eric Kripke, Supernatural holds a special place in the hearts of fantasy TV show enthusiasts, having run for over 15 years from 2005 to 2020. This remarkable series, notable for being the longest-running American fantasy TV show with live-action, gained notoriety not just for its gripping storyline but also for the misconceptions that developed around it. In addition to his work on The Boys for Amazon Prime Video, Kripke established an expansive universe in Supernatural that captivated and confused audiences alike. Now that the show has concluded its 15-season journey, it’s time to clarify some common misunderstandings stemming from its extensive lore.

Despite the series wrapping up, its influence remains strong. Fans continue to engage in discussions about plot points, character arcs, and the show’s ending, while some controversies may never reach a consensus. Here, we aim to dispel some myths that are prevalent among both avid fans and casual viewers. After all, Supernatural achieved a significant cultural footprint, even among those who’ve never watched a single episode.

1. It’s Just Cheesy Network TV

Misconception: It’s A Fun Guilty Pleasure, But Actually Lacks Depth

Outsiders often dismiss Supernatural as a guilty pleasure rather than acknowledging its artistic merits. Fans understand that this series isn’t merely light entertainment; it was groundbreaking for its time. Kripke’s storytelling prowess was evident in the first season, showcasing a dark fantasy replete with Americana themes.

The show’s blend of serialized horror and philosophical depth—alongside compelling character dynamics—created an engaging experience that won over a loyal fanbase. Its intricate plots and suspenseful season finales kept viewers hooked from start to finish.

2. Crowley Departed At The Right Moment

The Truth About Crowley’s Exit

Many fans lament that Mark Sheppard’s portrayal of Crowley ended too abruptly. While Crowley certainly made an impactful exit in the season 12 finale, sacrificing himself to seal Lucifer, it’s widely believed that his character had more potential to evolve within the narrative. Sheppard himself suggested that there were attempts to write Crowley out well before his exit, leaving fans yearning for more development from such a complex antagonist-turned-ally.

3. Dean Winchester: The Ladies’ Man

Myth: Dean Was The Show’s Leading Ladies’ Man

Dean Winchester is often characterized as the archetypal ladies’ man, but his romantic history falls short compared to that of his brother Sam. While Dean had his fair share of love interests, Sam’s connections were notably more substantial. Dean’s flirtation served as a comedic element that masked deeper issues surrounding his fear of intimacy and the weight of familial obligations.

4. “Carry On Wayward Son”Plays During Every Finale

Reality: The Song’s Actual Role in the Series

It’s a popular belief that Kansas’s iconic “Carry On Wayward Son”played during every season finale, but this is not the case. The song first appeared cleverly in the penultimate episode of season one, establishing a thematic connection between the brothers and their journey. As the series drew inspiration from classic biker films, its rock-infused soundtrack underscored the show’s rebellious spirit, rooted deeply in the American cultural landscape.

5. Kripke’s Five-Season Plan

Fact: Plans Were Tentative

While Eric Kripke had a vision for the first five seasons, the continuation of Supernatural was never strictly confined to that plan. His approach allowed for flexibility to accommodate audience feedback and emerging narrative developments. As Kripke noted, the vision for the show evolved naturally over time, shaped by the dynamic between cast and fans, reflecting the series’ organic growth.

6. No Character Dies For Good

Myth: Death Isn’t Permanent

Critics of the series frequently express frustration that no one truly dies in Supernatural. However, while the Winchester brothers faced near-death experiences repeatedly, many characters did face final demises that had a lasting impact on the narrative. This approach allowed the show to delve deeply into themes of life, death, and the afterlife—ideal for a series centered around these very concepts.

7. Dean’s Feelings For Castiel

Reality: Ambiguity and Subtext

The relationship between Dean and Castiel often sparked discussions about romantic subtext. While subtle hints suggest deeper feelings were present, the show never explicitly confirmed Dean’s love for Castiel. The show’s creators were aware of fan interpretations and played with the narrative, leaving many to wonder about the true nature of their bond.

8. One Main Character

The Truth: A Dual Protagonist Dynamic

The debate over whether Sam or Dean is the true protagonist often distracts from the reality that both brothers are essential to Supernatural. Their intertwined destinies reflect a narrative symmetry—each brother complements the other, forming the heart of the show’s storytelling.

9. The End of Supernatural

Misconception: There Will Be No More

Despite concluding at season 15, there remains speculation about potential new content. Both cast and network have hinted at revisiting the beloved franchise, and with discussions about future projects, the world of Supernatural might not be permanently closed off after all.

10. Later Seasons Are Worthless

Final Myth: The Show’s Decline in Quality

It’s often posited that Supernatural lost its charm after season 5. While some may perceive a dip in quality, true fans understand that the later seasons unveiled some of the show’s most profound storylines and character development. Indeed, the exploration of the narrative’s religious themes proved to be richer and more nuanced under the later creative guidance.

Ultimately, Supernatural has had a lasting legacy that continues to spark conversation and introspection. Whether through scholarly analysis or casual fan discussion, its impact on the fantasy genre—and television as a whole—remains significant.

Sources:
Collider,
YouTube,
Collider,
Collider

Source & Images