10 Canceled Sequels and Remakes We’re Thankful Were Shelved

In the realm of Hollywood, the tendency to churn out sequels and remakes is strikingly evident, leading many to question the intent behind these productions. Are they genuine extensions of beloved stories, or merely profit-driven endeavors that prioritize commercial gains over artistic integrity? A substantial number of recent cinematic releases certainly seem to lean toward the latter.

While a select few remakes and sequels manage to enhance the original films, many others merely tarnish their legacy. Fortunately, several poorly conceived projects have been halted before they could materialize, prompting fans to express disbelief at such questionable creative choices. A lackluster follow-up can leave an indelible mark on a superior film, so it’s refreshing to acknowledge the films that were ultimately never made.

10 Finding Nemo 2

Pixar’s Cancellation of Potential Sequels in the 2000s

Regarded as a milestone film within Pixar’s portfolio, Finding Nemo not only captured audiences but also won the Academy Award for Best Animated Feature. However, the idea of a sequel nearly tarnished its legacy. Following Disney’s acquisition of Pixar, they evaluated the studio’s upcoming ventures, including Circle Seven Animation, which was established to create sequels to popular Pixar titles. Among these plans was the contentious Finding Nemo 2.

This sequel envisioned introducing Nemo’s long-lost twin brother, Remy, who allegedly survived the initial barracuda encounter. The plot would see Nemo, Remy, and Dory embarking on a mission to locate Marlin after his disappearance. Such narrative shifts risked altering the emotional core of the original story. Ultimately, though fans were eager for a sequel, the cancellation of this concept—and others from Circle Seven—was a fortunate turn of events.

9 Taxi Driver 2

30 Years Later: The Unmade Sequel

Among the many unrealized projects from Martin Scorsese, a sequel to the iconic Taxi Driver stands out. This film remains an exemplary piece of cinema, yet for years it seemed untouched, until discussions sparked in the mid-2000s between Paul Schrader and Scorsese. Robert De Niro expressed interest in returning to the role of Travis Bickle, but ultimately, the script did not meet the expectations of its creative minds, leading to the project’s indefinite shelve.

8 Yellow Submarine

Why The Beatles’ Classic Should Remain Untouched

Regarded as a revolutionary piece in animation, Yellow Submarine broke conventional molds, beautifully complementing The Beatles’ music with its unique style. The dazzling visuals and inventive animation are pivotal to its charm, making any potential remake utterly redundant.

Previous animation techniques employed by Robert Zemeckis, particularly in films like The Polar Express, failed to resonate with audiences, serving as cautionary tales against employing similar styles in a Yellow Submarine remake. While remnants of a failed remake exist online, it only solidifies the notion that the original should remain pure.

7 E. T.The Extra-Terrestrial 2

The Unmade Darker Sequel Concept

E. T.the Extra-Terrestrial set box office records as the highest-grossing film of its time, a title it held for over a decade until superseded by Jurassic Park. Unsurprisingly, Universal Pictures expressed interest in a sequel despite the original’s complete narrative closure. Spielberg, along with Melissa Mathison, worked on a sequel script, but it proposed a much darker premise involving sinister aliens seeking to abduct Elliott and his friends.

This narrative pivot toward horror deeply contradicted the uplifting spirit of the original film. Fortunately, Spielberg opted to halt the project, preserving the legacy of his iconic creation.

6 Casablanca 2

Potentially Damaging Sequel to a Timeless Classic

Proposed in the 1940s, a sequel to the beloved film Casablanca was considered, which could have dramatically affected the film’s storied legacy. This sequel, originally titled Brazzaville, aimed to shed light on Rick as an Allied spy and complicate his relationship with Ilsa upon her return, muddled by a new character’s introduction, Maria.

If realized, this project could have fundamentally altered the perception of the original film, diminishing its impact. Luckily, this initiative was stopped before it could do any damage.

5 Escape From New York

A Long-Delayed Remake Fizzles Out

This defining 1980s film showcases Kurt Russell at his best, led by John Carpenter’s exceptional direction. Rumors of a lavish remake have circulated for nearly two decades; however, the project appears to have finally fizzled out, a seemingly good outcome considering the potential loss of the original’s charm. Various filmmakers, such as Joel Silver and Robert Rodriguez, were attached to the remake, but none managed to create a substantive version, reinforcing the belief that this film should remain untouched.

4 Forrest Gump 2

The Missed Opportunity for Sequel Land

After achieving phenomenal success in 1994, adaptations of Winston Groom’s sequel, Gump & Co., were considered by Paramount Pictures. Hanks, Zemeckis, and Roth explored ideas for depicting Forrest’s life in the 1980s. Ultimately, however, they determined that a sequel was superfluous to the original, which concluded the narrative seamlessly. Fans curious about exploring the sequel can look up Groom’s novel.

3 Ei8ht

The Unnecessary Sequel on the Horizon

Se7en remains one of David Fincher’s most iconic works, featuring a compelling narrative and stellar performances. However, a sequel titled Ei8ht was announced that threatened to undermine the original’s haunting conclusion by vaguely related content about a detective possessing psychic abilities. The project’s deviation from Se7en‘s grim realism led both Morgan Freeman and David Fincher to reject it. Eventually, a reworked concept morphed into the 2015 film Solace, which failed to impress critics.

2 Sarface

The Long-Standing Re-Remake Stalls

As one of the most notable remakes in film history, the 1983 version of Scarface redefined gangland dramas. In 2011, Universal announced a re-remake intended to modernize the story, but despite changing hands among several renowned directors, this project now seems to be officially abandoned.

1 Pocahontas

Disney’s Cautious Approach to Live-Action Adaptation

Although Disney continues to reinterpret its classic animated features into live-action films, Pocahontas remains conspicuously absent from this trend. Originally envisioned for this treatment alongside other iconic films from the 1990s, discussions regarding its remake have been abandoned due to evolving social attitudes, which highlight the film’s problematic elements.

The simplified retelling of historical events poses significant challenges when engaged with modern perspectives.Any attempt at a live-action remake is likely to meet fierce critical scrutiny, requiring Disney to navigate contentious historical narratives while striving to remain kid-friendly, possibly diluting the film’s integrity.

Source & Images