1 Major Flaw in Star Trek: Section 31’s Villain Lacks Coherence

1 Major Flaw in Star Trek: Section 31’s Villain Lacks Coherence

Warning: This article contains significant spoilers for Star Trek: Section 31.

The newest addition to the Star Trek franchise, Star Trek: Section 31, introduces a complex antagonist named San, portrayed by James Hiroyuki Liao. While the storyline unfolds primarily on Stardate 1292.4 during the 24th century’s “lost era, ”it also features flashbacks that delve into the past of Georgiou (played by Miku Martineau) in the Mirror Universe’s Terran Empire. This time travel aspect raises some intriguing questions about the characters’ timelines and relationships.

San’s Age in Star Trek: Section 31 Raises Concerns

The 70-Year Gap Between San’s “Death”and His Return

One of the most puzzling elements surrounding San is the apparent discrepancy regarding his age. He seems to remain unchanged since his supposed death, which complicates the narrative timeline. San and Georgiou are contemporaries, both having been teenagers in the early 23rd century. San faked his demise prior to the events of Star Trek: Discovery, which takes place in 2257, while Star Trek: Section 31 is set in 2324—over sixty years later. This raises the question: why does San appear to be the same age as when he “died”?

In the series, Fuzz (Sven Ruygrok) mentions that San developed an immunity to his own poison, which plays a role in the plot, yet it fails to clarify why he did not physically age. On the other hand, Georgiou’s lack of aging is justifiable due to her time-travel adventures, including a significant leap to the 32nd century with the USS Discovery. This temporal journey allowed her to return to the early 24th century seemingly unscathed by the passage of time. However, it should be noted that the crew of Starfleet remains unaware of this significant gap, leaving inconsistencies in their perceptions.

The most straightforward explanation for San’s chronological oddity could be that he also time-traveled, yet Star Trek: Section 31 does not clarify this intriguing possibility. The series appears to overlook the substantial 60-year gap between the 23rd and 24th centuries, along with the chaotic state of the Terran Empire during this time, which adds further confusion to the continuity established in the Mirror Universe lore.

Unveiling San’s Ambitious Agenda

Was San’s Aim to Become the Terran Emperor?

San’s motivations are multifaceted—he is introduced as the enigmatic buyer orchestrating the acquisition of a powerful weapon known as the Godsend from the weapons dealer Dada Noe (Joe Pingue).Noe, also hailing from the Mirror Universe, serves as a crucial player smuggling the Godsend into the Prime Universe for San’s ambitious plan.

Strategically, San’s objective is to utilize the Godsend at the Passageway, a dimensional portal shaped by twin ion storms, to proclaim himself Emperor of the Terran Empire. His ultimate intent is to unleash the Godsend on the Federation, facilitating the empire’s bold conquest.

Partnering with San is Fuzz, an infiltrator within Alok Sahar’s (Omari Hardwick) Section 31 Alpha Team. Fuzz’s role is pivotal—he manipulates Section 31 to divert their attention away from San, instigating discord among the operatives. Remarkably, Fuzz, who embodies a microscopic Nanokin integrated within a Vulcan robot, has ambitions of his own—to aid San in obliterating the Federation and reigning alongside the Terran Empire.

Ultimately, San’s plan meets a tragic end at the hands of Emperor Georgiou, who hears him declare his enduring love for her with his final breath. Intriguingly, Georgiou never addresses the anomaly of San’s unchanged appearance over the years, leaving fans questioning the continuity yet again.

For further information and insights regarding this topic, you can check the source here.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *